by scottychaos
I dont know about "phenomenal"..its ok, but it clearly stands out as photoshopped to me:
1. The contrast of the locomotive is VERY different than the rest of the scene.
the caboose is very low contrast, murky, as is the entire foreground and the entire background.
the locomotive however is much higher contrast..it shouldnt be if it was really there,
it should match the contrast of the overall scene.
2. Look at the pilot ("cowcatcher") of the loco, where it falls behind the steps of the caboose..
some black and white lines are just randomly stuck in there..
3. The loco is clearly a 4-4-0..however in the photo its a 2-4-0.
the second set of pilot wheels is simply gone, missing..
it should be between the kid and the guy to the right of the kid. (our right)
its just not there.
4. The front driver is also missing, on the far side..
there is just a white space where it should be.
5. Look at the far rail..
under the caboose, its that murky low-contrast grey..
then the rail falls under the loco, and it suddenly becomes pitch black..
follow it back..it mysteriously turns to pure white inbetween the sets of tender trucks..
6. On both sets of tender trucks, all the wheels on the far side are missing..
the tender is balancing on 4 wheels, all on one side..
I guess I dont really mind that its photoshopped..
I just dont understand why it would be..
(although it does bug me a bit, because a historic photo has been altered without being indicated as such..
I do photoshop alterations of train pics myself..but I always make sure they are clearly labeled as "fakes"..)
such as: http://gold.mylargescale.com/scottychaos/LVRR_SD70.html
Scot
1. The contrast of the locomotive is VERY different than the rest of the scene.
the caboose is very low contrast, murky, as is the entire foreground and the entire background.
the locomotive however is much higher contrast..it shouldnt be if it was really there,
it should match the contrast of the overall scene.
2. Look at the pilot ("cowcatcher") of the loco, where it falls behind the steps of the caboose..
some black and white lines are just randomly stuck in there..
3. The loco is clearly a 4-4-0..however in the photo its a 2-4-0.
the second set of pilot wheels is simply gone, missing..
it should be between the kid and the guy to the right of the kid. (our right)
its just not there.
4. The front driver is also missing, on the far side..
there is just a white space where it should be.
5. Look at the far rail..
under the caboose, its that murky low-contrast grey..
then the rail falls under the loco, and it suddenly becomes pitch black..
follow it back..it mysteriously turns to pure white inbetween the sets of tender trucks..
6. On both sets of tender trucks, all the wheels on the far side are missing..
the tender is balancing on 4 wheels, all on one side..
I guess I dont really mind that its photoshopped..
I just dont understand why it would be..
(although it does bug me a bit, because a historic photo has been altered without being indicated as such..
I do photoshop alterations of train pics myself..but I always make sure they are clearly labeled as "fakes"..)
such as: http://gold.mylargescale.com/scottychaos/LVRR_SD70.html
Scot
~ Scot Lawrence
Moderator: Lehigh Valley
Co-Moderator: Anthracite Railroads
Scot's railroad webpages
Moderator: Lehigh Valley
Co-Moderator: Anthracite Railroads
Scot's railroad webpages