gokeefe wrote:The problem with low density accommodations is that the market is simply too narrow for them. Private car rates also place a ceiling on how high Amtrak can go. Why pay $3,000 a night for a bedroom when you could potentially have an entire car?
Amtrak's fundamental answer to all of this is volume. Totally selling out at peak damages their ability to grow the market year over year. They should be able to run longer trains in the winter to Florida and make a boatload of money doing it. If it worked for SCL until the very end I see no reason why it can't work now.
Not sure if I follow the first paragraph. Iowa Pacific seemed (based on articles I read, which is hardly scientific) to have at least 15-20 people per trip on its Pullman trips on the City of New Orleans at high prices. Iowa Pacific seemed to have multiple cars per train, which of course is a recipe for failure, but if Amtrak could have 1 car per train dedicated to a "premium" service, charging those 15-20 people, in total, what a regular sleeping car would cost, that seems like a winner. Via offers this on the Canadian, or so I've read.
For the second paragraph: yes, railroads make money on volume. Isn't adding another car for premium-class service adding volume? If the Silver Meteor can have 4 sleepers on now around Christmas, I'd think that it could add at least one or two more with added "premium" and "discount" services.