gokeefe wrote:I find it interesting that it is so uncommon for Amtrak to restore service on any route or segment that was discontinued in the pre-war era. This topic has seen quite robust discussion and the only comparable to Rockland is the Ethan Allen Express to Rutland.
The Rockland extension truly is a unique event for Amtrak. Interesting to consider all of this as efforts move forward on reactivation.
In a way it makes sense when you consider the nature of the pre- vs post-WW2 train-offs.
The service that was discontinued in the 1920's and 30's was mostly marginal branch-line stuff that couldn't compete with automobiles even given the modest-- by modern standards-- road improvements of the time. Think, for instance, of the dozens of southern New England services that the NYNH&H replaced with buses after WW1.
The post-war train-offs of the '50s and '60s, on the other hand, were primarily driven by competition from airlines and the interstate highway network.
Those are two different animals. Local-road congestion is never going to get bad enough for anyone to consider restoring, say, the Ridgefield Branch shuttle between Branchville and Ridgefield Center. Congestion on I-95 and at Logan and LaGuardia, on the other hand, actually
is bad enough to have driven large numbers of people back to the rails.
Also, there's an important difference between the upcoming restoration of Rockland service and Whitehall-Rutland.
New York-Rutland service in the old days ran Troy-Johnsonville-Hoosic Jct-North Bennington on the B&M, then headed north on the Rutland. If the B&M passenger main between Troy and Johnsonville were still intact, that would have been the logical route for a resuscitated Rutland train. However that line has been gone for ~50 years. That leaves no choice but to use the D&H.
Boston-Rockland, on the other hand, is a straight-out restoration of what was once, a very long time ago, a premier summer service. The great historian Samuel Eliot Morison (1887 - 1976), in his history of Mount Desert Island, wrote about taking that very train as a boy on his way to his family's summer house on the Maine coast in the 1890's.