by cclune
Is CP ever going to go EMD again?? They are seemingly buying all GE.
Railroad Forums
Moderators: Komachi, Ken V
If EMD can make another SD40-2, then yes.I think they already did. It's called the SD70M!
trainiac wrote:I think the jury is still out on thatIf EMD can make another SD40-2, then yes.I think they already did. It's called the SD70M!
Engineer Spike wrote:Everyone says that the anti EMD attitude came from the bad luck with the SD90MAC fleet. I think that this is stupid. The model with its H prime mover was still in its teething stages. If CP had gone with the 70MAC, I think that things would be different. BN/BNSF seems to have good luck with their several hundred. I never recall having any trouble with them.One of my sons is a CP engineer and has encountered SD70MACs as run-through power a couple of times. Hated the things. Much prefers the 4400/ES44
GE has had some problems with the new ES series. This could be why CP tested the BNSF EMD units. We will have to wait for the economy to pick up. When that happens, we'll see what we get.
steamguy wrote:Having run both new EMD and new GE locomtives on the CNR, I have to agree with him. You would not believe how many times I have uttered the phrase "not ANOTHER 8800(SD70M-2)."Engineer Spike wrote:Everyone says that the anti EMD attitude came from the bad luck with the SD90MAC fleet. I think that this is stupid. The model with its H prime mover was still in its teething stages. If CP had gone with the 70MAC, I think that things would be different. BN/BNSF seems to have good luck with their several hundred. I never recall having any trouble with them.One of my sons is a CP engineer and has encountered SD70MACs as run-through power a couple of times. Hated the things. Much prefers the 4400/ES44
GE has had some problems with the new ES series. This could be why CP tested the BNSF EMD units. We will have to wait for the economy to pick up. When that happens, we'll see what we get.