by ACeInTheHole
Since the VII thread keeps derailing.. Lets bring that single level replacement discussion in here please.. Have at it.
Railroad Forums
Moderators: GirlOnTheTrain, mtuandrew, Tadman
Sir Ray wrote:OK, I'll start - what were the reasons the Amfleet shells couldn't be rebuild (again)?Question isn't "could they be rebuilt again" so much as "would rebuilding them again be more cost-effective than purchasing new equipment," right? Even stainless steel isn't indestructible; at some point it seems like the shells, frames, etc. are going to have metal fatigue issues that make rebuilding a major challenge.
Tom6921 wrote:How about building new coaches based off the Amfleet design? If the design worked once, why not again?Needs bigger windows, no reason to go with a tubular shape, better HVAC system design would be desirable. Fix all that and you're getting close to a Viewliner coach! Whatever form the next coach takes, it'll look something more like an Acela coach or Viewliner I think.
Tom6921 wrote:How about building new coaches based off the Amfleet design? If the design worked once, why not again?