Railroad Forums 

  • Transition from link/pin to AAR knuckle couplers

  • General discussion about locomotives, rolling stock, and equipment
General discussion about locomotives, rolling stock, and equipment

Moderator: John_Perkowski

 #1537307  by CarterB
 
Recently saw collectors photo of a AAR transition coupler that had both knuckle and link/pin capability.
What was the period of time these transition couplers were in use? I assume 1880s to 1900?
Attachments:
Early_Janney-type_AAR_coupler.jpg
Early_Janney-type_AAR_coupler.jpg (145.17 KiB) Viewed 1601 times
 #1537324  by TrainDetainer
 
The Janney/knuckle coupler was patented in 1873, so it's use would have started from shortly before then. The transition was slow at first and really picked up in the late 1880s, and knuckle couplers were mandated by 1906.The original Janney knuckle was designed with the link slot for the transition, and you can still see these knuckles in limited use at various museum operations, so the actual use period is now almost 150 years. IIRC the Miller Hook couplers (appeared late 1860s - 1890s) also accepted links, so the split Janney knuckles could also be used for towing those equipped cars (mostly passenger equipment).

Side note - In the pic you used, the coupler body is marked AAR and looks more like a type E or very late D, and the AAR didn't exist before 1934, so it wasn't made until at least 28 years after link and pin couplers were outlawed. Later (post 1906/7) transition knuckle revenue users would have been logging roads, traction roads, industries and other special users, not mainline RRs.
 #1537326  by toolmaker
 
It appears this specific coupler remains in "as cast" condition and was not used for the pin and link setup. The bores are still rough from the manufacturing process.
 #1537517  by TrainDetainer
 
That one looks like an early D type or maybe even pre-D MCB type with that short head. Easier to tell if you can get a pic where we can read the full patent dates and other info on both sides of top face. For mainline transition use - again, it would have started around 1872-ish with pre-patent trials and came to an end around 1906/7 with the general ban on link and pin. IIRC there were a few stragglers that didn't get changed out to knuckles by the 1906 effective date, but many roads did start to convert early on when they realized that the knuckle type couplers were not just more expensive, but better for train operations and therefor the bottom line. Between the regulation and the critical mass of everyone else doing so, there wasn't much point in holding out with the old stuff for the mainlines.