by Railjunkie
NortheastTrainMan wrote: ↑Sun Jul 07, 2024 1:25 pm Regarding the NYP - NHV issue affecting Amtrak on July 6 and 7, it makes sense imo for Amtrak to announce service suspended from NYP - BOS, to whom I presume are those travelling from NYP - BOS, not 100% sure about the other way around.Funny I have seen and been part of numerous hey you need to get over to GCT and meet your train at Harmon or reverse, same idea. Most of the time people grumbled a little but didn't walk around like a bunch of zombies. "IF" Amtrak had it set up with Metro North to cross honor tickets they may had it set up so they would have employees at certain points to make sure passengers were able to make the transfer, I have seen it done both at GCT and Penn. Perhaps not it would have depended on how management wanted to handle the situation.
Why? Because most travelers don't know much about trains, or public transportation. I've run into a ton of people who don't know the difference between GCT & NYP.
Of course us here on this forum can figure a few things out, but I don't think those who aren't familiar with public transportation would be too thrilled to have to travel from NYP to GCT in this sweltering heat. I'm sure Lyft & Uber are expensive too in Midtown. Think for a second, someone unfamiliar with public transportation and / or NY in general, would they be willing to take the subway from NYP to GCT, take a Metro North train to New Haven (not one terminating at Stamford) and then an Amtrak from NHV to BOS, or points east? Possibly yes, there's always a small handful willing to do that, but the vast majority would not, and would probably have some "nice" things to say.
Similar for the inverse. If Amtrak (which I think they did, correct me if I'm wrong) ran trains from BOS to NHV, would they be happy to transfer to Metro North to reach NY? Depending on their final destination it might be easier. If it's NY, they might compromise with GCT. If it's say, maybe somewhere south of NY, it could be an issue.
Plus, there's a difference between deliberate misinformation from news stations & just plain ignorance when it comes to railroads. I'm wagering 90% of the latter (I'm being generous). For example, I highly doubt a news anchor would know the difference between a P32 and a P42. Should they? In theory yes, but we all know what happens in reality most of the time. Misinformation in both cases, nonetheless.
All in all, good points are being raised. Just remember the average person isn't as knowledgeable or cares to be as knowledgeable about trains as we are.
Same circus different tent