Okay but my point is if you read what Vanderhoef has been saying he's actually been pretty careful to NOT make it sound like he's complaining about taxes. He wants more value.
As far as the payroll tax on businesses, to say that it is causing some of them to layoff workers or go out of business I think that's a little extreme. I think businesses get quite a lot of value from the services the MTA provides.
Look the problem is the economy is soft and tax revenues are way down. They need money to maintain the current level of service. Rockland is part of the MTA District. They have to chip in for everything not just the part they use.
Or they can possibly leave the district and pay for everything themselves. Which I think might cost them more than they pay now.
Remember the storm damage from Hurricane Irene? How everyone was saying the MTA was reacting too slowly? Imagine if Orange and Rockland Counties had had to repair the damage by themselves? We'd probably be still waiting.
As far as the payroll tax on businesses, to say that it is causing some of them to layoff workers or go out of business I think that's a little extreme. I think businesses get quite a lot of value from the services the MTA provides.
Look the problem is the economy is soft and tax revenues are way down. They need money to maintain the current level of service. Rockland is part of the MTA District. They have to chip in for everything not just the part they use.
Or they can possibly leave the district and pay for everything themselves. Which I think might cost them more than they pay now.
Remember the storm damage from Hurricane Irene? How everyone was saying the MTA was reacting too slowly? Imagine if Orange and Rockland Counties had had to repair the damage by themselves? We'd probably be still waiting.