emannths wrote:Ok, how are 10-rides used for fare evasion? Either you have a valid ticket or you don't...
On days when conductors can't or don't collect fares then passengers with a 10 ride don't get punched. Based on Twitter complaints, it is a not infrequent occurrence - and usually due to overcrowding or some other operational situation that makes it impossible / unsafe for conductors to move through the coaches collecting tickets. So it isn't (in my mind) intentional fare evasion on the part of passengers and also not due to 'lazy' or irresponsible operations by train crews (as some Twitter trolls assert quite loudly), it is just an artifact of circumstances.
Eliminating the paper 10-ride mitigates the problem somewhat, but doesn't completely eliminate it. Presumably some of the passengers will switch to mTicket single fares or 10 rides, and I'm sure that 'management' thinks people 'activate' their tickets as soon as they sit down (which would mitigate the problem of tickets not being checked - once activated, the ticket is used). My observation is that people don't 'activate' their mTickets until a conductor is almost to them, so I don't think the switch to mTicket will actually mitigate the 'fare evasion' problem.
If former paper 10-ride passengers switch to monthly passes, then that certainly solves the problem. At the other end of the spectrum, some passengers might actually just buy multiple (many) single ride tickets, which won't mitigate the problem.
My concern is that former paper 10-ride passengers will start paying cash (especially on inbound trains), which will present problems for train crews trying to collect fares on trains full of passengers.
The paper 10-ride (or mTicket 10-ride) provides an advantage for passengers who (due to out-of-town business travel or any number of reasons) don't travel to Boston on the CR for enough trips to justify ('break-even' on) a monthly pass. Agreed, it isn't a cost savings or a discount and it is only a convenience, but if you're not travelling on the CR (or combined travel with subway) to justify a monthly pass, then there is no discount available, which makes the 10-ride attractive.